Nancy Enderle’s Homily from Oct. 18, 2026

Nancy EnderleHomilies Leave a Comment

As part of the eucharist liturgy here at Holy Wisdom, we gather in a circle and join hands as we share the Prayer of Jesus that the sisters and liturgical committee chose for this Monastery. The prayer begins with the words, “Holy One, our only home.”

The first time I read the prayer, it jolted me out of the passive recitation that sometimes I slip into during a worship service. “Holy One, Our only home.”  What compelling words to address the Divine! I was used to, and expecting, the opening phrase I have recited since childhood: “Our Father who art in heaven”.  Praying this Prayer of Jesus, I recognized something that felt more intimate and accessible.

Indeed, the phrase “our only home” creates a profound sense of grounding, safety, and identity.  It draws on the timeless and archetypal images from myths like the Odessey, in which Odysseus valiantly strives to return home, and fairy tales like the Wizard of Oz, where Dorothy discovers companions and her own inner strength for her journey home.

As compelling the word and image of “home” is, the impact of the phrase is increased by the preceding word “only”.  As an adjective modifying the word “home”, “only” accentuates the exclusive and exceptional qualities of this home. When considered as a metaphor, our only home represents the foundation of our lives, our north star, our resting place, our truest self. Here phrases like coming home to yourself touch on that place where we feel most deeply aligned with who God calls us to be, where our unique gifts and experiences create a sense of meaning and purpose.

When the scriptures talk about God, all sorts of stories point to this exclusive/singular experience of being rooted and placed in relationship with the one (and only) God. Jesus teaches that the most important commandment is to Love God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your mind. We are beckoned toward exclusive and total allegiance to God. To offer our devotion to any other influence or being other than God is considered idolatry.

For centuries accusations and charges of idolatry carried a more explosive charge than in our current vernacular and culture. The Hebrew Scriptures expose how often the followers of YHWH turned their hearts toward other gods, and how often God reprimands and ultimately forgives them: the Golden Calf in Exodus, the worship of Baal by Ahab and Jezebel, King Nebuchadnezzar’s Golden Image in the Book of Daniel, to name a few.  Scriptures also define idolatry beyond the worship of physical statues and include letting anything, such as pride, arrogance, or dis-ordered desires take the central place of God in our heart. In today’s Gospel passage these issues of idolatry and allegiance play a prominent role.

The story unfolds in Matthew’s Gospel when Jesus is asked a question. The question is raised by disciples of the Pharisees and the Herodians, (an unlikely pairing of partisans who represent both the power of Rome and organized religion.) These unlikely schemers come together to “trap” Jesus by providing him with a lose/lose situation. First, they try to butter Jesus up with praise, then shift to their objective. Their question is short and to the point: “is it lawful to pay taxes to the emperor, or not?” The tax in question is a denarius census tax issued to each person on behalf of Rome. The trap for Jesus is that by answering yes, he could be perceived as colluding with Rome and justifying Roman occupation and the oppression of the Jews. This would be perceived as an unpopular at best, and a betrayal at worst by many of his followers. On the other hand, if Jesus responds no, he could become suspect of revolutionary actions against Rome.

The wisdom of Jesus’ response has several layers. After asking to see a denarius coin – he asks, “whose image is on the coin?” They answer “Caesar’s”, and he replies, “well, then give to Caesar the things that are the emperor’s, and give to God the things that are God’s.” 

If you separate the first clause on its own, it declares the tax should be paid, because Caesar’s image inscription on the coin falls under “the things that are the emperor’s.” But the central point is made in the final clause where the listeners – including all of us – are brought to speculate what is included in ‘things that are God’s’ and ultimately discern what belongs to whom. If you take Jesus’ own teachings and references from Hebrew Scriptures highlighted throughout Matthew, as well as his preaching about the coming of God’s Kingdom, it is difficult to imagine that Jesus would consider that anything falls outside of ‘the things that are God’s.’

Interestingly, most Bibles organize the content of this passage under the sub heading The Question About Paying Taxes. This topical preview falls quite short of what is really happening in these verses in Matthew. In Jesus’ response the issue is deftly transfigured from an economic or political question to a theological one. On a deeper and more challenging level the coin tells us about who we are, and what is our only home. No one is exempt from deciding who and whose we are.

Another layer of this teaching concerns how these verses have been used to justify or legitimize governing powers. Given the breadth of Jesus’ compassion and concern for the poor and oppressed, I do not believe he was suggesting turning a blind eye to Caesar’s use of taxes or giving political wrongdoing a green light. This teaching is also dangerously misused when we separate a citizen’s allegiance to government from the heart’s allegiance to God. If everyone and everything belongs to God, then this teaching calls us to discern what is due to each authority—and to recognize when obedience to one creates a moral conflict with the other. In other words, when do the laws or actions of governing powers contradict the life God calls believers to live?

In his book, Jesus a New Vision, Biblical scholar Marcus Borg writes, “The politics of compassion did not lead Jesus to withdraw from culture, but to a passionate mission to transform the culture of his day – because he saw God as caring about what happened to human beings in history, he saw culture as something to be transformed not simply rejected or legitimated.”

Friends, I don’t know about you, but I experience a disturbing dose of moral conflict with the language and actions of our government almost daily – or several times each day to be more accurate. It forces the question and response – is our allegiance to those systems or the Holy One, whose compassion has claimed our hearts and shaped our lives? It is from this question of ultimate allegiance that the prophets raised their voices against idolatry; against rulers who turned away from caring for the people and focused more on drawing praise and adulation for themselves. And it is from this question of ultimate allegiance the each of us must find our way through the challenges of actions that hurt or destroy that which belongs to God – which is everything.

The issue raised by Jesus, is one which we each are invited to wrestle with in our private lives as we make choices about our behaviors and actions. It also impacts our shared lives. That is why there is great significance to standing in this Assembly Hall and declaring the God is the Holy One – our only home. That is why saying it together matters. That is why joining our voices together and saying “Holy One, our only home” holds such comfort and challenge. If our north star, our truest heart, is indeed the Holy One we pray to and build our lives around, is our home base, then there is certainly occasion to find strength in the circle of joined hands this morning, in the heartbeat of devotion to God and the practice of the better in the face of the bad.  May God help us discover what is ours to do and gives us courage for the living of these days.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *